Plimoth Plantation

“You have to be careful,” warned Kathie. “They encourage you to go into houses and rummage around. But if they find you in their house, they’ll challenge you on it. They speak in 17th century English and it’s intimidating.”


She was talking about Plimoth Plantation, a living history museum that recreates life as it was for the English colonists who arrive in Massachusetts in 1620, on the Mayflower. I’d read similar comments about Plimoth, on various trip review sites. Plimoth takes their history, and historical interpretation, very, very seriously. Their interpreters each embody a real-life colonist and they stay strictly in character – no acknowledgement of or straying into the 21st century. And woe be to the visitor who deviates from this 17th century norm.

But I was forewarned so this, I decided, could be fun.

I would rummage through drawers and cabinets and if caught, say that I was looking for valuables to pilfer. Then I’d ask to capture their soul in my flashing black box.  I sincerely hoped that would result in me being the center of my very own Crucible-like drama.

Boston 186a

Alas, none of that happened.

The museum must have gotten enough negative feedback to decide to tone down their Puritanesque application of historic interpretation because the interpreters we encountered were all pleasant, informative and accommodating.  They were still 17thcentury, but in the usual historical interpreter way – wink, wink, nod, nod.

Boston 191Priscilla Alden didn’t seem the least bit fazed when we wandered into her house to ask her about her new roof (her husband, John, just put it on) and her garden (she uses many of the plants for physick).

We made ourselves at home in one empty house.  We bounced (gently) on their bed, moved their amour, and tried on some of their clothing. No one came in to accuse us of trespassing during our free-for-all, however.

My favorite parts of the museum came before the English settlement. In the building where the ticket center, intro film and gift shop was located, was an exhibit area where the crafts people worked – they who make the reproduction products that furnish the village and are used by the interpreters at the museum.  We spoke at length to a First Nations Canadian who was making head dresses for the staff in the Wampanoag Homesite.

IMG_2660aThis is a head dress made of porcupine and deer.  I said that it reminded me of a Hawaiian head dress.  The artist said that he thought there were similarities about head dresses through time and across cultures. Someone had mentioned to him that his head dresses reminded them of Roman centurions.

“It’s a guy thing,” said Kathie.

After leaving the craft area, we had a short walk up a hill to a site built to resemble a Wampanoag village. The Wampanoag were the people who, pre-English, occupied the area that’s now the lower New England states.

The staff in the village are Native – on that day, all but one was Wampanoag – but not role players. They wear 17th century clothing and engage in 17th century tasks, but present as 21st century people there to teach about Wampanoag history and culture. We spent most of our time speaking with and watching a woman who was finger weaving a bag. I got so interested that I bought a book about finger weaving after I got home, and found a traditional figure weaving workshop that is taking place in West Virginia in October, that I might attend.

IMG_2661aI enjoyed our time at Plimoth very much – much more than I expected, in fact.  I wasn’t that enamored of Jamestown Settlement, a similarly reproduced colonial village/living history museum in Virginia, so I thought this might be much of the same.  I think my enthusiasm with Plimoth had to with their staff.  I found the Plimoth staff knowledgeable, enthusiastic and engaging and so was completely engaged by them.

My only disappointment was that no one accused me of sorcery. But we’d be on to Salem the next day, so there was still hope.


Gallery | This entry was posted in Massachusetts and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

14 Responses to Plimoth Plantation

  1. Kathie says:

    Hope you can decipher the instructions for the finger-weaving so you can show me. Those were seriously gorgeous. My favorite part of the plantation village was talking gardening with one of the householders. Excellent redware watering system.

  2. How much did they charge for admission?

  3. Neat! Probably good that they toned it down really – I’m sure it did piss off lots of people. So many folks just don’t know how to roll with it these days! 🙂

  4. cat9984 says:

    When we were in Virginia, we were advised against going to Jamestown because there really wasn’t much to justify the drive and expense. Apparently it was good advice.

    • There are two Jamestown attractions in Virginia. One is the actual Jamestown where John Smith and the colonists lived. Run jointly by National Park Service and Preservation Virginia, it’s an active archaeological site with a great museum. Definitely worth visiting.

      The other is Jamestown Settlement, which a couple of miles from the real Jamestown and is a recreation of a 17th century village, with costumed interpreters. If you go to the real Jamestown first, you realize that the recreation isn’t very authentic. And I wasn’t that impressed with the interpreters. I hate giving any history venue a bad review, but it just didn’t do anything for me. Maybe someday I’ll go back and give it another chance.

  5. flanaganm says:

    I agree about the Jamestown Settlement vs Plimoth Plantation opinion. Having grown up with the rather large and very interactive Plimoth, it was kind of a let down to visit the Jamestown and Yorktown living history museums with my class this spring. Were they fun, yeah, just not as much fun as I remember having on my class trip to Plimoth. If I were given the option to go again, I would decline and head to the very nicely done NPS Jamestown site located on actual Jamestown.

    • I was just at Yorktown, but didn’t get to the living history museum. I understand that they’re currently renovating it, to make it bigger and better. We’ll see. Jamestown NPS definitely was better than the Settlement.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s